Mac Studio M4 Max (128 GB) vs MacBook Pro M5 Max (128 GB) for local LLMs

The verdict is the new MacBook Pro M5 Max (128 GB) at $6,699, unless a used Mac Studio M4 Max (128 GB) costs under about $5,400. The LLMCheck index puts Qwen 3.6-35B-A3B at 130 tok/s (community run) on it against ~105 tok/s (estimated) on the used Mac, and both fit the same 93 of the 130 models.

Bandwidth
546 / 614
GB/s
Unified memory
128 / 128
GB
Models that fit
93 / 93
of 130
Qwen 3.6-35B-A3B
estimated105 / community130
tok/s

Spec sheet: Mac Studio M4 Max (128 GB) vs MacBook Pro M5 Max (128 GB)

Mac Studio M4 Max (128 GB)MacBook Pro M5 Max (128 GB)
ChipM4 MaxM5 Max
GPU cores40-core40-core
Memory bandwidth546 GB/s614 GB/s
Unified memory128 GB128 GB
Price—
used or refurbished only — check current listings
$6,699
Apple list price, checked 14 Nov 2026 · with 2TB storage
Price per GB—$52
Models that fit (of 130)9393
Best local LLM hereQwen3.8-Flash-Next estimated45 tok/sQwen 3.6-35B-A3B community130 tok/s
Qwen 3.6-35B-A3Bestimated105 tok/scommunity130 tok/s
Price per tok/s on Qwen 3.6-35B-A3B—$52
Form factora desktop (bring your own display)a laptop with a battery and a built-in display
Where to buyUsed / refurbished (Apple no longer sells it new)New · build-to-order from Apple
Bandwidth and RAM per configuration from data/macs.json (Apple’s figures); prices are Apple’s US list prices on the date shown. “Best local LLM” is the Best by Mac headline pick for each config. Winners in bold.

The models both run, side by side

Every speed below is the LLMCheck index’s figure for that exact configuration — the same number its Mac Studio M4 Max (128 GB) and MacBook Pro M5 Max (128 GB) pages print, with its provenance mark. Across the 90 shared models with a figure on both, the MB Pro M5 Max column is a median ×1.10 of the Mac Studio M4 Max column.

ModelSizeMac Studio M4 Max tok/sMB Pro M5 Max tok/sRatio
Qwen3.8-Flash-Next125B MoEestimated45community47×1.04
DeepSeek V4 Flash Vision-Exp305B MoEestimated32estimated39×1.22
GLM-5.3-Flash320B MoEestimated23estimated27×1.17
Qwen 3.6-35B-A3B35B MoEestimated105community130×1.24
Inkling-Small caveat276B MoEestimated38estimated42×1.11
DeepSeek V4 Flash284B MoEestimated29community39×1.34
KAT-Coder-V2.535B MoEcommunity94community89×0.95
Nemotron 3.5 Lightning30B MoEestimated117community117×1.00
North Mini Code 1.030.5B MoEestimated114community120×1.05
Qwen3.8-27B27.8Bestimated26community31×1.19
Nanbeige4.3-33B33.1Bcommunity25community25×1.00
Qwen3-235B-A22B235B MoEestimated23estimated26×1.13
Nemotron 3.5 Super VL 120B-A12B120B MoEcommunity51community36×0.71
Ling-3.0-flash-VL124B MoEestimated48estimated53×1.10
Recursive Flint39.8B MoEestimated89community123×1.38
Provenance key
sourced
Published figure — vendor or press review
estimated
community
Linked individual run — blog, forum or submission

Showing the top 15 of the 93 shared models, in Best-by-Mac suitability order for the Mac Studio M4 Max (128 GB). Every other pair of Macs: the compare tool’s two-Mac mode.

What only one of them runs

Nothing: both fit the same 93 of the 130 models in the LLMCheck index, because both have 128 GB. The difference is speed and price.

Price per GB and per token/s

The new MacBook Pro M5 Max (128 GB) costs $6,699 (Apple list, 14 Nov 2026): $52 per GB and $52 per tok/s on Qwen 3.6-35B-A3B. A used Mac Studio M4 Max (128 GB) matches that $52 per tok/s at about $5,400; below that price it is the better value on decode speed alone. The index records no used prices: check current listings, and weigh the warranty and the remaining years of macOS support.

Which to buy, by use case

Bottom line: The new MacBook Pro M5 Max (128 GB), unless the used one costs under about $5,400.

🛒 Where to buy these two Macs

Renewed stock of the 128 GB Mac Studio M4 Max varies: check the memory in the listing before you buy. Amazon does not stock the MacBook Pro M5 Max (128 GB): Apple builds it to order.

As an Amazon Associate, LLMCheck earns from qualifying purchases. Affiliate links cost you nothing extra and never influence the verdicts.

Where these numbers come from

Each speed is decode (generation) tok/s from the LLMCheck index for that exact configuration: the lower-median measured run on that chip where one exists (a filled square is a published figure, a hollow circle a community run), otherwise an estimate from the memory-bandwidth model (hollow diamond, printed with a tilde). LLMCheck runs no tests of its own. Prompt processing (prefill) depends on GPU compute rather than bandwidth, and the index does not estimate it; Apple’s M5-generation GPUs add per-core Neural Accelerators aimed at that work.

FAQ: Mac Studio M4 Max (128 GB) vs MacBook Pro M5 Max (128 GB)

Which is better for local LLMs, the Mac Studio M4 Max (128 GB) or the MacBook Pro M5 Max (128 GB)?

The verdict is the new MacBook Pro M5 Max (128 GB) at $6,699, unless a used Mac Studio M4 Max (128 GB) costs under about $5,400. The LLMCheck index puts Qwen 3.6-35B-A3B at 130 tok/s (community run) on it against ~105 tok/s (estimated) on the used Mac, and both fit the same 93 of the 130 models.

How much faster is the MacBook Pro M5 Max (128 GB) than the Mac Studio M4 Max (128 GB) for local LLMs?

Decode speed on Apple Silicon follows memory bandwidth: the MacBook Pro M5 Max (128 GB) reads memory at 614 GB/s, the Mac Studio M4 Max (128 GB) at 546 GB/s. The LLMCheck index puts Qwen 3.6-35B-A3B at 130 tok/s (community run) against ~105 tok/s (estimated). Across the 90 shared models with a figure on both, the median gain is 1.10x.

Do the Mac Studio M4 Max (128 GB) and the MacBook Pro M5 Max (128 GB) run the same models?

Yes. Both fit the same 93 of the 130 models in the LLMCheck index.

What should a used Mac Studio M4 Max (128 GB) cost to beat a new MacBook Pro M5 Max (128 GB)?

About $5,400 or less. At that price it matches the new Mac's $52 per tok/s on Qwen 3.6-35B-A3B ($6,699 at Apple list, checked 14 Nov 2026). The LLMCheck index records no used prices, so check current listings, and weigh warranty and macOS support.

What is the best local LLM for each of these Macs?

On the Mac Studio M4 Max (128 GB): Qwen3.8-Flash-Next at ~45 tok/s (estimated). On the MacBook Pro M5 Max (128 GB): Qwen 3.6-35B-A3B at 130 tok/s (community run). These are the headline picks of the LLMCheck Best by Mac pages: the best-ranked model that reaches 15 tok/s on that Mac and has a standard Mac runtime.

Related